International Graduates and the CASC: Why the Gap Exists and What Closes It
International medical graduates pass the CASC at lower rates than doctors who qualified in the UK. That is well documented, and most international candidates know it before they sit. What they are rarely told is why, or which part of the gap is within their control.
This guide sets out what the evidence shows, what it does not, and the part that preparation can change: the kind of consultation the exam assumes. I trained in the UK, examined for the CASC and now practise outside it, so I have seen this from both sides of the table.
What the evidence shows
At the September 2026 sitting, the overall pass rate was 52.27%, and 68.69% among doctors in UK training. That comparison is between candidates in UK training and everyone else, not between international and UK graduates, but it points the same way.
An evaluation of the College's CASC masterclasses, published by the GMC in 2023, reported a 41 percentage-point difference in MRCPsych pass rates between white UK trainees and international graduates from ethnic minority backgrounds. It described the gap as unexplained. The research it cites points to several causes, some of them outside the candidate's control: unfamiliarity with UK-style assessment, less access to support from seniors and peers, isolation in some workplaces, and concern about bias.
Two conclusions are fair. The gap is not evidence that international graduates are weaker psychiatrists. And part of it is a matter of familiarity, which preparation can address.
The consultation the exam assumes
The College is explicit that the CASC is structured around the UK core psychiatry curriculum and UK guidelines. The stations therefore assume a particular kind of consultation: the one a UK patient would expect from a UK psychiatrist. Doctors who trained and practised elsewhere are often excellent clinicians in their own systems, and some of what serves them well there works against them here.
In my experience as a former examiner, the international candidates who fell short were rarely short of knowledge. More often, they ran a good consultation of a different kind. Five differences come up again and again.
1. The patient decides with you
In many health systems the doctor recommends and the patient, or the family, accepts. The CASC assumes shared decision-making: you explain the options, including doing nothing, check what matters to the patient, and agree a plan together. A clear recommendation is still expected. What loses marks is a plan delivered as an instruction, with no room for the patient's view.
2. The adult patient is the person you are accountable to
Where families are closely involved in care, it is natural to share information with them and to defer to them. The UK starting point is different: an adult with capacity decides what is shared, and with whom. That does not mean shutting relatives out. You can listen to a relative's concerns without breaching confidentiality, and you can explain what you are able to discuss and why.
3. Risk is named out loud
In settings where suicide and violence carry stigma, or legal consequences, doctors learn to ask about them indirectly. The CASC expects direct, calm questions about thoughts of self-harm and suicide, risk to others and, where children are involved, safeguarding. Candidates who hint at risk without asking about it leave the examiner unsure whether they assessed it at all.
4. Plans refer to UK services and law
A plan that would be sound in Cairo, Riyadh or Lahore can still read as incomplete in a UK station if it does not use the UK's structures: the GP, community mental health and crisis teams, and the legal frameworks that apply in England and Wales, such as the Mental Health Act 1983 and the Mental Capacity Act 2005. You do not need to recite them. You do need to know where each fits, so your plan sounds like it belongs in the system the station describes.
5. Language is plain, and checked
The issue is rarely accent. It is register. Candidates trained in systems where doctors speak with formal authority often use technical terms with patients or relatives, or deliver information without checking it has landed. The CASC rewards plain words, short explanations and a check of understanding before moving on. That is a habit, and habits can be practised.
What closes the gap
None of these differences is a gap in clinical ability, and all of them can be learnt in weeks rather than years. Four steps make the difference:
Learn the marking domains before you practise. The College evaluation found that many candidates had not understood the domains, although they are published. Four of the six are about how you conduct the consultation, not what you know. How the CASC is actually marked explains them.
Read the UK guidance behind the common stations, with an eye on what it says to the patient, not only on the drug doses and criteria. Shared decision-making, confidentiality and capacity run through almost every station type.
Learn the UK service map. Know what a GP, a community mental health team and a crisis team do, and when each legal framework applies, well enough to put them into a plan without stopping to think.
Get feedback from someone who knows the UK standard. Ask them to watch for the five differences above specifically. Colleagues trained in the same system as you will often not notice them, because they share the same habits.
If you are new to the exam, The MRCPsych CASC Explained covers eligibility and format. If you are sitting in January, the 12-week revision plan shows where this fits in the weeks left, and if you are resitting, what to do after a fail comes first.
Free from MedLex: The Examiner's Briefing and The Examiner's Error Log
The Briefing explains how the CASC is actually marked and the errors examiners see most often. The Error Log is a one-page self-audit to fill in after every practice station, so the person watching you can record what they actually saw, including the habits this article describes.
Frequently Asked Questions

Dr. Ahmed Abouelghit
Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist and founder of MedLex. Writes on medico-legal practice, expert witness work and institutional leadership.
Master the MRCPsych CASC Examination
Structured consultant-led practice, realistic simulated stations, and candidate-tested clinical consultation frameworks.
